Susan G. Garner

February 11, 2021


ARNER - Susan Grace
(nee Castleberry)
Garner 68, of Fredonia, NY, formerly of Niagara Falls, NY, passed away at Brooks Memorial Hospital, Dunkirk, NY February 11, 2021 after a brief battle with Covid-19. Susan was born August 24, 1952 in Dunkirk, NY, and raised in Dunkirk and Fredonia, the oldest child of the late William G. and Clara R. (Burchett) Castleberry. A 1970 graduate of Fredonia High School Susan obtained a Bachelor of Science in Exceptional Education from Buffalo State College in 1974. In 1975 she attended and graduated from Moody Bible Institute in Chicago, IL. Susan then returned to Buffalo State College and obtained her Master of Science in Exceptional Education in 1978. Susan taught in Buffalo Public Schools for a total of 29 years before retiring in 2014. Susan loved cats, dogs, the beauty and wonder of nature, music, reading and teaching. She enjoyed helping others and in her retirement took up painting and crafting. A lifelong learner she especially enjoyed her lessons and friendship with the WCA Home Lifestyles Coordinator Jennifer. "Those who love teaching help others love learning." Susan was a member of the Niagara Presbyterian Church, The Buffalo Teachers Federation, Beaver Meadows Audubon, and The National Wildlife Association. In addition to her parents Susan was predeceased by her husband and best friend Charles Bennett, who died June 20, 2019. Susan leaves behind her loving little dog Nathan and his selfless adopted mother Rita. She is survived by one brother, William P. (Bonita) Castleberry of Middleburg, FL, and two sisters, Karen A. (Daniel) Geibel of Republic, WA and Sally C. (Patrick) O'Malley of Dunkirk, NY. Many nieces, nephews, cousins and friends also survive.  In lieu of flowers, Susan suggested donations may be made to the Erie County SPCA, The Niagara Presbyterian Church, or The WCA Assisted Living Home of Fredonia.

To send flowers to the family or plant a tree in memory of Susan G. Garner, please visit our floral store.


You can still show your support by sending flowers directly to the family, or by planting a memorial tree in the memory of Susan G. Garner


Erie County SPCA
300 Harlem Road, West Seneca NY 14224
Tel: 1-716-875-7360

Niagara Presbyterian Church
3712 Military Road, Niagara Falls NY 14305
Tel: 1-716-297-3585

WCA Assisted Living Facility
134 Temple Street, Frredonia NY 14063
Tel: 1-716-672-7961

© 2021 Acacia Park Cemetery. All Rights Reserved. Funeral Home website by CFS & TA | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy